The Freest Being in the Universe
Part 5
Garbage In, Garbage Out: The Surfer in Shackles
The fifth instalment of my book The Freest Being in the Universe, serialised here on the web. This is chapter four of five on the Englehart Surfer: Silver Surfer vol. 3 #19–24 (January–June 1989) and Silver Surfer Annual #2 — a heartbreak engineered by Titan, a love story exiled off-panel, fables written under protest, and the backstage civil war that nearly broke the run before its finale.
August 2026
Get it on:
Amazon.com →
Amazon.de →
Amazon.co.uk →
This article series is the full text of the book.
If
you'd like to support the author, please feel free to purchase
a physical copy or the Kindle ebook.
On the page, this stretch reads like a breather. The black hole recedes in the mirror, a romance is blown apart by outside interference, and a string of mournful, self-contained stories fills the months while the Kree–Skrull war comes slowly to the boil. But the real drama of these months took place off the page. This is the period in which Marvel and Steve Englehart went to war with each other, a conflict the writer waged partly in public, using the credits box itself as a protest banner. To understand it is to read these issues quite differently. What looks like a lull is really a hostage situation, and the hostage left notes.
Let us be honest about where we stand, too. By most measures this is the low point of the run so far: the thinnest stories, the unhappiest circumstances, a book visibly working against its own grain. There is no pretending otherwise. But it is a valley we must cross to reach the last peak, because everything that makes the finale glorious is being quietly wound up here, in the dark. Read it as the deep breath before the plunge. The plunge is worth it.
Heartbreak, by Titan (#19–20)
Silver Surfer vol. 3 #19–20: Firelord's ambush, and Eros's cruel manipulation.
First comes the hangover from the In-Betweener affair. Issue #19 opens with everyone going their separate ways. The five restored Elders use their gems to vanish, Galactus packs Nova off to find him a meal, and the Surfer ferries Reed, Sue and Franklin home to Earth. Both heralds quietly suspect that the errand is really meant to keep them apart. It is the first hint of Englehart's strangest and boldest idea of the late run: that the devourer of worlds may be developing feelings for his own herald.[1]
Meanwhile two fiery figures come knocking at Reptyl's door in the Coalsack. They are Firelord, a former herald of Galactus, and Eros of Titan, the charming adventurer known to the Avengers as Starfox, and they are hunting the pirate Nebula, who destroyed Firelord's adopted homeworld of Xandar. Reptyl, ever the transactional lizard, has no Nebula to sell, but he happily trades what he does have: the Silver Surfer's whereabouts, in exchange for a promise to leave him alone. Firelord wants the Surfer badly. He blames Norrin Radd's original betrayal of Galactus for the chain of events that killed his friend and predecessor as herald, the Air-Walker. The logic is as thin as the logic of grudges usually is.
The ambush that follows is a nasty piece of emotional business, because the real weapon is not fire at all. While the Surfer efficiently dismantles Firelord (the fight itself is barely a contest), Eros quietly uses the power over emotions that is his birthright as a son of Titan, supposedly to keep Nova out of harm's way. When the dust settles, Nova rushes past the victorious Surfer to cradle the beaten Firelord and kiss him. The Surfer wins the battle and loses the girl in the same panel.
Issue #20 is the fallout, and it contains a memorable character moment. The mightiest being in the sector, humiliated in love, flies to a remote asteroid field and takes out his frustrations on the rocks. It is the cosmic tantrum in its purest form, and the definitive proof of how far Englehart's emotional, temperamental Surfer has travelled from Stan Lee's marble saint. The worst of it, we learn, is that Eros manipulated both of them, Nova into her swoon and the Surfer into passively watching it happen. It is a violation that leaves Starfox himself quietly ashamed. Nova, for her part, asks Galactus for leave to go and console the Surfer, is refused, and begins to wonder, not unreasonably, why her master cares so much.
A real ethical horror lurks beneath this scrap of soap opera, and it deserves a name, because it rhymes with a lesson we met all the way back in the Surfer's early history. Eros does not force anyone to do anything. He merely reaches into their feelings and adjusts them, and he tells himself that he has good reason, since he was keeping Nova safe. What he actually does is rob two people of the authorship of their own emotional lives. Nova's tenderness towards Firelord and the Surfer's paralysis are made to feel, from the inside, exactly like their own. That is the violation.
When the Surfer, over Manhattan, decided that he knew what humanity needed and attacked it for its own good, we called it the tyranny of the person who cares too much and trusts too little. Eros commits the intimate version of the same crime. To manage another person's feelings without their knowledge is to treat them as a puppet and not as a person, however kindly your motive. It is to decide that their real preferences matter less than the ones you would like them to have.[2] The sign that this is wrong, and not merely helpful, is Starfox's own shame. Some part of him knows that a consent you had to bypass was a consent that mattered. Emotional manipulation, the scene insists, is no lesser harm for leaving no bruise. It steals the one thing that makes a choice a person's own.
Around the wound, the pieces of the war are set out afresh with Englehart's usual density. Reptyl, expecting trouble, hides a secret cache of weapons on a remote world and maroons his crew there as guards, with Clumsy Foulup in charge. And in a cave on that nowhere moon, something in a purple cape waits patiently for Clumsy to wander in. (Readers who have come this far know exactly which severed head that is.)
The second Kree–Skrull war escalates as Empress S'byll's forces unveil their new champion: the Super-Skrull, freshly liberated in Annual #1 and now fighting for the claimant to the throne who can make use of him. On Zenn-La, Supreme Leader Nenora herself comes calling, all diplomacy, to ask Shalla-Bal to summon the Silver Surfer for a talk. The empress declines, for she will call him only in a true emergency, and adds, pointedly, that if pressed the Surfer might well side with the Skrulls. Nenora laughs inwardly at an irony only she can savour. Shalla-Bal, unsettlingly, half-catches the thought. Remember that flicker.
And on Earth, at the edge of everything, a green woman is breaking into an airport at night and staring at aeroplanes that cannot take her where she needs to go. Mantis is alive, and pining for the stars.
The Odd One Out (#21)
Silver Surfer vol. 3 #21: Marshall Rogers' fill-in, the Obliterator's revenge on Zenn-La.
Issue #21 (March 1989) is a curiosity, and Englehart's own website is briskly honest about it. It was a fill-in, the only issue of the first thirty-one that he did not write.[3] Marshall Rogers returns one last time, plotting as well as pencilling, with Michael Higgins writing the script. The result is a tale of revenge that sits awkwardly in the timeline. The Kree attack the Surfer despite their truce, nobody mentions Nova, and sharp-eyed fans have long suspected that it was made for a slot around #11.
The Obliterator, the weapon-obsessed Elder whom the Surfer disarmed into catatonia back in #6, has been rotting on his prison world ever since, sustained by a single promise. The Contemplator's astral form once appeared to him, urged him to rearm and vowed to send a ship. The ship never came, for the excellent reason that Captain Reptyl ate the Contemplator in the meantime. (The fill-in winks at the main storyline even while sitting outside it.) So the Obliterator, tired of waiting, steals a ship and aims his rage at the most hurtful target available: Zenn-La. Cue a cry for help from Shalla-Bal and a Kree armada in the Surfer's way. What follows is a slugfest on the homeworld against an immortal who, fought to a standstill, goes so far as to threaten the entire planet before the Surfer finally puts an end to his rampage. It is a serviceable action issue wearing another era's clothes, and the fact that it is the least compromised story of this stretch tells you something about what was happening to the issues around it.
Behind the Curtain: Marvel Goes Into Reverse
Now for the story that anyone with a time machine would really want to witness. On his own website, Englehart divides his Silver Surfer run into three phases, as he does his runs on Fantastic Four and West Coast Avengers from the same period. The middle phase begins here, with what he calls Marvel's decision to go into reverse.[4]
The company was under new management. Jim Shooter, who had approved the series, was dismissed in 1987, and Tom DeFalco now sat in the Editor-in-Chief's chair. The mood throughout the company turned against the kind of long, braided serial storytelling that overturned the established order, which was exactly what Englehart had been doing. He had done it on the FF, where he had benched Reed and Sue, and on the Surfer, where he had built a cosmic epic twenty issues long. The directives came down.
The first order, as Englehart tells it, was to abandon the approach that had finally made the Silver Surfer sell and return to the formula that had failed for twenty years. That meant single-issue stories with a moral, starring a Surfer who once again pined for Shalla-Bal: a lost love who, as he acidly notes on the site, "hadn't been his girlfriend since issue 2 of this run". You can watch the order take effect as it happens. After eighteen issues of interlocking saga, the book abruptly changes down into self-contained fables about melancholy wandering.
The second order is the one that should make every fan of cosmic Marvel gasp. Englehart wrote an issue, intended as #23, that teamed the Surfer with Thanos and Mantis, and he was informed that Thanos was not allowed to appear in Silver Surfer.[5] The script would have united the God of Death (Thanos) and the Goddess of Life (Mantis) more than a decade before Englehart finally staged that pairing in 2001's Avengers: Celestial Quest. It was simply shelved.
The irony needs no underlining, but let us underline it anyway. Within eighteen months Jim Starlin, the creator of Thanos, would take over this very title, resurrect Thanos in its pages, and launch from it Thanos Quest and The Infinity Gauntlet, one of the most celebrated cosmic storylines Marvel ever published. The Mad Titan was banned from the book that was about to become his home. Englehart noticed too. His site remarks, with an almost audible sigh, that the prohibition would have come as news to Starlin.
The plan to make Mantis the Surfer's companion was equally dead, since the editors had vetoed her as his regular partner, and so her storyline was evacuated into Englehart's other books. The backup story in Annual #1 had already carried her across to Avengers West Coast. The reunion and the farewell themselves landed in his Fantastic Four #323–325, in the middle of Inferno, a crossover that ran through the whole Marvel line, of all places.[6] There, at last, the Surfer and Mantis found each other again on Earth. There, too, she left her mortal body to follow her Cotati kindred into space, gone as completely as if she had died. Readers of Silver Surfer itself never saw it happen. The book's own captions in #23 and #24 merely lament that the moment the Surfer learned Mantis lived was the moment he lost her for ever, and then direct the reader to another series. The love story at the heart of the run's first year ends off-panel, in someone else's crossover, by editorial order.
And here the credits box becomes a battlefield. Englehart, by his own account, made sure that the public knew what was going on. The clearest signal was his own name. Across this compromised stretch his byline begins to fracture. Issue #22 still carries his full name, but from #23 the coldly anonymous "S.F.X. Englehart" takes over (S.F.X., he would note, for "Simple Sound Effects"). The backup stories of the second annual carry the estrangement to its limit[7]: the affectionate old nickname from Marvel's offices in the 1970s, "Stainless Steve" Englehart, appears like a memory of better days beside the same "S.F.X.", and on one story his name is dropped altogether in favour of "John Harkness", the pseudonym he kept for work he refused to own.
Harkness was working overtime that season. Over on Fantastic Four, Englehart says, he was ordered to bring back Reed and Sue and undo every change he had made. The whole of #326–333 went out under the pseudonym, while the real FF slept in suspended animation and dreamed the stories he had been forbidden to tell. A writer signing his work in mounting degrees of estrangement, in full view of a hundred thousand readers a month, is one of the strangest and most poignant protests in Marvel's history.
It came to a head in what Englehart describes as a period of "civil war inside Marvel". And then came the armistice. The Editor-in-Chief offered him a deal: "I could have six months or so to wrap up SILVER SURFER with no interference, but then I'd be gone." He took it.[8] In the event the "six months or so" stretched to seven. The finale ran across seven issues, #25 to #31 (July 1989 to January 1990), with a double-sized issue at either end. The first issue under the new arrangement, #25, was titled "Back from Black?", and the question mark was deliberate. As he notes with satisfaction, the question answered itself. The war he had been building since issue #2 would be fought after all. (His site's postscript on the whole affair is magnificently acidic: "When I left, Clumsy Foulup ruled the Kree Empire, and four years later, Marvel was bankrupt.")
The Forced Fables (#22–24)
Read against that backstage drama, the three "formula" issues become fascinating relics. They are professionally crafted and handsomely drawn by Ron Lim and Tom Christopher, and they are visibly the work of a book writing with its hands tied. Each is a fable with a moral, and each is soaked in mourning for someone beloved.
“Monsters... from the Ego!” (#22, April 1989)
Silver Surfer vol. 3 #22: “Monsters… from the Ego!”
This issue is the best of the three, because it builds on the run's real history and does not conjure a moral from nothing. Ego the Living Planet (an Elder, you will remember, and the venue for the conspirators' conclave back in #4) ambushes the Surfer in deep space, pins him to his own surface and locks the board in orbit.
What is Ego's grievance? Long ago, while Thor, Hercules and Firelord held the maddened planet at bay, Galactus bolted a colossal starship engine to Ego's south pole. It was a leash, driving him endlessly through space so that he could never again menace inhabited worlds, and the strain of resisting it has left the planet ravenous.[9]
He intends to digest the Surfer for the calories. The escape shows the Surfer at his most resourceful. Unable to blast his way free, he fights his way to the engine itself, recognises his old master's handiwork and seizes control of it. He aims the Living Planet straight at the nearest sun until Ego, screaming, agrees to let him go. Asked to destroy the leash as a parting favour, the Surfer coolly declines. Galactus chained this particular monster for a reason.
He flies off, sensing as he goes that a world has somehow moved within Earth's solar system.
That thread pays off elsewhere, in Fantastic Four #325 (April 1989), another book Englehart was writing under the same duress. Chasing the disturbance, the Surfer finds the Human Torch stranded and unconscious in deep space near Mercury, marooned there by the time-travelling conqueror Kang in the course of a scheme involving Mantis. The Surfer joins forces with the Fantastic Four and Mantis against Kang, the Cotati and their servants, the Priests of Pama. The battle ends in a draw. The plant-beings flee into "the realm of pure thought", and Mantis leaves her own body behind to follow them and rescue her son.
Englehart almost certainly meant this as a holding action for Mantis, a way to set her gently aside until he could pick up her threads in his own time. As he put it afterwards, he "took her untold storyline and moved it, with middling success, to the FF": a salvage operation for a character whom Marvel's upheaval would otherwise have left stranded.[10]
“Alien!” (#23, May 1989)
Silver Surfer vol. 3 #23: “Alien!”
Grief-stricken over Mantis, the Surfer drifts to a world that he personally spared from Galactus generations ago. There he finds its people setting their own planet ablaze. The fire is a desperate beacon, a plea for help from the stars against a "dragon" that has been killing them one by one from behind a screen of invisibility. He strips the creature's concealment away and confronts it. The dragon insists that the accusations are lies. The fable grinds on to its bitter end, with the creature dead and nobody feeling saved.
It is exactly the kind of one-off morality tale the directive demanded, delivered with a shrug you can almost feel through the page.
“G.I.G.O.” (#24, June 1989)
Silver Surfer vol. 3 #24: “G.I.G.O.”
The last of the fables sends the still-mourning wanderer to a gleaming crystalline world that proves to be a single vast computer, Motherboard 49.7[11]. It identifies him as a herald of Galactus, and therefore a threat to its very existence, and hurls endless automated armadas at him. The one real pleasure here is visual: Randy Emberlin's inks over Ron Lim's pencils lend the artwork a crisp freshness that the thin story cannot muster on its own.
The Surfer battles his way to the machine's heart for a debate with a paranoid operating system. And the title gives the game away. Englehart's own site drily notes that G.I.G.O. is a computing term: Garbage In, Garbage Out. From a writer being force-fed a formula he despised, that is about as close to signing the issue "under protest" as a title can come.
Fans combing the run have noticed how little these issues give a summariser to work with, compared with the twenty that went before. The writer made sure that we would notice the shrinkage.
The Second Obligation: Silver Surfer Annual #2 (1989)
The year's annual is the other item produced under the yoke. It is the Surfer's chapter of Atlantis Attacks, the fourteen-part crossover about a serpent god that slithered through every Marvel annual of 1989.[12]
Drawn by Ron Lim with a committee of inkers, and co-credited to Renée Witterstaetter, it opens on a peculiar hook. Cleaning a green residue from the underside of his board, the Surfer unthinkingly channels the Power Cosmic through it and brings it to life. He has resurrected Ghaur, high priest of the Deviants, a monstrous offshoot of humanity. Ghaur promptly sets off for Earth to hunt for the Serpent Crown and summon the elder god Set, whose origin the issue pauses to recount. The Surfer, drawn back into the Kree–Skrull war and the defence of Zenn-La, cannot give chase.
The back pages carry a chapter of the crossover's history of the Serpent Crown, written by Peter Sanderson, and a solo tale for Nova in which Englehart, never off duty as a cosmologist, restates his grand design: our universe balances on the trinity of Eternity, Death and Galactus.
Readers then and since have ranked the annual as eminently skippable. The games with the credits cluster around this very corner of the run, which is the clearest sign of how its writer regarded the obligation. Its one lasting service is to the calendar. By the time it went on sale, the issues beside it on the stands were already something else entirely.
What This Chapter Teaches Us
This is the chapter in which the book's two stories, the Surfer's and Englehart's, become one, and the lesson lives where they overlap. On the page, a being who was finally set free finds himself constrained all over again. He is pushed into wandering fables, robbed of the companion he had chosen and told where he may and may not go. Off the page, the writer who set him free endures the same thing. He is handed a book and then ordered to unmake the very qualities that had made it work. The chapter's title, "The Surfer in Shackles", names both prisoners at once.
What Englehart does with those shackles is the real lesson, and it is a bracing one about integrity under constraint. He does not walk off the job, and he does not coast. The "forced fables" are still professionally built, still handsomely drawn, still solid comic books. But he also refuses to pretend that the constraint is not there. He signs his estrangement in the credits. He titles a compromised issue "Garbage In, Garbage Out". He lets the reader see, without ever breaking the story, that this is honest work done under protest.
There is a difference, this chapter insists, between compromise and capitulation. To compromise is to keep making the best thing you can inside limits you did not choose, while telling the truth about those limits. To capitulate is to make the limits your own, and to start believing that the smaller thing is all you ever wanted to make. Englehart compromised and never once capitulated, and the credits box is the proof.
And then there is the deal itself, which is the cleanest moral in the whole backstage story of the run. Offered six months of freedom to finish the book properly, at the cost of his job on it, he took the offer. He traded the position, with its pay cheque, its security and its future, for the right to give his story a real ending. Most of us are never asked the question so starkly. But it is worth knowing where you stand, because some version of it comes to everyone who makes things: what is finishing this well actually worth to you? Englehart's answer, which is also the answer of every artist who ever chose the work over the sinecure, was that an ending you are proud of outlasts a job you are not. Thirty-five years later the job is long gone and the ending is still here. He was right.
Hold on, too, to the smaller lesson tucked into the "forced fables". Even these wandering, grief-soaked one-offs, written to order, are shot through with real emotion. The man was mourning Mantis on the page while mourning his own creative freedom off it, and the grief was unfeigned in both places. Sometimes the honest work you do while trapped carries just as much of you as the free work ever did. Suffering that is neither dramatised nor dodged has a way of getting into the heart of what you write.
The Shackles Come Off
For the deal had been struck. Six months, no interference, one ending: everything Englehart had been seeding since a spy smiled her way onto the Kree throne was finally cleared for detonation. The Super-Skrull has found his empress. The severed head has found its stooge. Shalla-Bal has half-perceived a thought she was never meant to catch. And issue #25 is titled "Back from Black?", with a question mark that the next seven issues will spend erasing.
The finale is next: the second Kree–Skrull war in full, with shapeshifting restored, empires aflame, a pirate admiral, a puppet Supreme Intelligence, the Living Tribunal explaining the universe, and the single most gloriously absurd coronation in Marvel's history.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which Silver Surfer comics does Part 5 cover?
Part 5 covers Silver Surfer volume 3, issues #19 to #24 and Annual #2, published in 1989. It follows a heartbreak engineered by Titan and the stand-alone fables Englehart wrote under protest.
Who wrote and drew these comics?
They were written by Steve Englehart and drawn by Ron Lim. The one exception is issue #21, a fill-in plotted and pencilled by Marshall Rogers and scripted by Michael Higgins.
Is The Freest Being in the Universe free to read online?
Yes. The complete book is free to read here on marincomics.com, all six parts, richly illustrated. If you would like to support the author, you can also buy the paperback or Kindle edition on Amazon.
What is The Freest Being in the Universe about?
The Freest Being in the Universe is Marin Balabanov's chapter-by-chapter appreciation of Steve Englehart's cosmic Silver Surfer, volume 3, issues #1 to #31, published from 1987 to 1990. It retells every issue and asks what the stories teach us about freedom, identity, grief, and finding a third path beyond false either-or choices.
Notes and Sources
- Englehart left the book with #31 (January 1990) without ever paying off this thread directly. Thankfully, it did receive one pay-off, at the climax of Ron Marz's “The Herald Ordeal” (Silver Surfer vol. 3 #70–75, 1992): when Galactus's cast-off herald Nova is killed by her replacement, Morg the Executioner, Galactus reacts with rare grief — stripping Morg of the Power Cosmic — a flash of genuine feeling that vindicates Englehart's tease without ever developing it into the jealous romance he seemed to be building. See Silver Surfer vol. 3 #75 (December 1992), Marvel Database — marvel.fandom.com. ↩
- The principle that persons must be treated as ends in themselves and never merely as means is the second formulation of Immanuel Kant's Categorical Imperative (Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals, 1785). Covert emotional manipulation — however well-intentioned — is a paradigm case of using another as a mere means by bypassing their rational consent. ↩
- On #21's fill-in status and credits, see steveenglehart.com and the Grand Comics Database (comics.org). ↩
- Steve Englehart, “Silver Surfer 22-24”, steveenglehart.com: “when Marvel made its decision to go into reverse”, he was told “to go back to the formula which hadn't worked: one issue stories, with a moral, while he pined for his lost girlfriend (who hadn't been his girlfriend since issue 2 of this run).” — steveenglehart.com. ↩
- Steve Englehart, “Silver Surfer 22-24”, steveenglehart.com: “I wrote an issue (what would have been #23) with Thanos and Mantis, and was told Thanos was not allowed in SILVER SURFER.” — steveenglehart.com. ↩
- The Surfer/Mantis reunion and Mantis's departure into space were staged in Englehart's Fantastic Four #323–325 (1989) — a Kang-and-Cotati cosmic subplot running alongside his Inferno tie-in issues (Fantastic Four #322–324) — rather than in Silver Surfer itself. See Fantastic Four #325, Marvel Database — marvel.fandom.com. ↩
- On the precise per-issue attribution — including “S.F.X. Englehart” on Fantastic Four #323–325 and “John Harkness” on Fantastic Four #326–333 — see the discussion of the omnibus credits at Captain Comics — captaincomics.ning.com — and Englehart's own site. ↩
- Steve Englehart, “Silver Surfer 25-31”, steveenglehart.com; he sums up taking the deal as “I took one for the team.” — steveenglehart.com. ↩
- The engine on Ego's south pole dates to Thor #228 (October 1974, by Gerry Conway and John Buscema): after a maddened Ego absorbed the Wanderers, Thor — aided by Hercules and Firelord — held the planet off until Galactus fixed a massive starship engine to it, driving Ego endlessly through space so he could no longer threaten inhabited worlds. Ego explains as much in Silver Surfer #22, which footnotes the reader back to that issue. The thruster therefore long predates the Elders' conspiracy of the Englehart run; Ego's grievance against Galactus is genuinely ancient. See Thor Vol. 1 #228, Marvel Database — marvel.fandom.com. ↩
- Steve Englehart, “Fantastic Four 322-325”, steveenglehart.com — steveenglehart.com. ↩
- Steve Englehart, “Silver Surfer 22-24”, steveenglehart.com — steveenglehart.com. ↩
- Silver Surfer Annual #2 (1989). Credits per the Grand Comics Database (comics.org). ↩